IJAS: Troubling Ruling Against Slobodan Dukić – Relying on Journalistic Source Does Not Prove Unauthorised Data Collection

Illustration: ChatGPT

The Independent Journalists’ Association of Serbia (IJAS) expresses concern over the ruling of the Higher Court in Smederevo, which found journalist Slobodan Dukić guilty of unauthorised collection of personal data and fined him 30,000 Serbian dinars. The Basic Court in Smederevo had previously acquitted Dukić twice, but the Higher Court upheld the private prosecutor’s appeal and reversed the judgment.

 

IJAS is particularly concerned by the court’s reasoning, which raises questions about the conditions under which journalists can collect and publish information of public interest. The Higher Court concluded that Dukić knew his conduct was prohibited, although the private criminal complaint contained no such allegation. In IJAS’s view, the court thereby went beyond the scope of the charge.

 

We also draw particular attention to the misapplication of Article 88 of the Law on Personal Data Protection, which provides for exemptions from many of the law’s provisions when data is processed for the purposes of journalistic investigations and the publication of information in the public interest. In practice, however, personal data protection rules are often interpreted too broadly, without sufficient regard for the nature of journalistic work. As a result, journalists may be held responsible for violating the right to privacy even when the data in question was never published or was altered so that the person could not be identified. This practice can unjustifiably restrict media freedom and the public’s right to be informed.

 

The judgment also states that Dukić published the private prosecutor’s address and unique personal identification number (JMBG). However, the article in question did not publish the address, and the identification number had been altered so that the full number could not be determined.

 

The court’s assessment of Dukić’s use of journalistic sources is particularly troubling. The court stated that Dukić, as an investigative journalist, could and should have known that his conduct was prohibited. In its reasoning, the court noted that he had obtained some of the data by submitting a freedom of information request and had obtained the rest from his sources. It concluded that the mere fact that Dukić received a copy of the private prosecutor’s employment record book “from his source” “indicates that the document was obtained without authorisation”. IJAS considers the fact that a journalist received a document from a source insufficient, on its own, to support that conclusion.

 

The Law on Public Information and Media protects journalists’ right to keep their sources confidential. An exception applies to information concerning a criminal offence or its perpetrator if the offence carries a minimum prison sentence of five years and the information cannot be obtained by other means. Article 41 of the Criminal Procedure Code also protects source confidentiality and provides for exceptions in cases involving serious criminal offences, including when disclosure is necessary to prevent such an offence.

 

This interpretation disregards the importance of media freedom, which is safeguarded by the Constitution of the Republic of Serbia, domestic legislation, international conventions and the case law of the European Court of Human Rights. Protecting journalistic sources is a cornerstone of free and independent journalism and an essential safeguard for freedom of expression and the public’s right to be informed. Undermining that protection, particularly by treating reliance on a journalistic source as proof of unauthorised conduct, can discourage sources from speaking to journalists, jeopardise investigative journalism and restrict the public’s right to know.

 

Investigating corruption is nearly impossible without relying on journalistic sources. Public institutions cannot be expected to point out potential irregularities or corrupt practices in their own work when responding to freedom of information requests.

 

Adopting this approach would open the door to indirect pressure on journalists and media outlets. Fear of the consequences of relying on sources could lead to self-censorship and significantly restrict media freedom.

 

Independent Journalists’ Association of Serbia

Belgrade, 19 November 2026

 

Tags

highlighted news

Related posts