Szalai: N1, Nova should remain independent

photo: N1

Pavol Szalai of Reporters Without Borders spoke to N1 about the changes in the media scene, warning of the fallout if N1 and Nova are no longer independent media outlets.

 

N1 – We saw the political change here in Serbia. What do you expect from the media now, but also from state institutions and politicians?

 

Szalai – The first thing I expect is a different approach to communication with journalists. There should be no political attacks, all journalists should have access to press conferences, and there should be no hate speech against reporters. This has been one of the biggest threats until now under the rule of Aleksandar Vucic, who was really a press freedom predator, attacking journalists almost daily and focusing on N1 and Nova S.

 

I hope, and believe, that we will not hear this from the new government. I also hope that the Serbian Progressive Party will re-evaluate its approach to journalists, because it will still be in the new parliament. It should change its communication and create conditions for normal dialogue with journalists on issues of public interest.

 

N1 – However, in his defeat speech, he again attacked N1 and Nova S. He said we were paid and that our reporting was actually responsible for his defeat. How do you see these messages?

 

We also saw his comments yesterday after the attack on TV Informer, when people entered the television station. He said something similar, suggesting that the incident would have been all over the news if it had happened at N1 or Nova S.

 

Szalai – I once again condemn former President Aleksandar Vucic’s attacks against N1 and Nova S. Apparently, he blames them for his electoral loss. However, it is not the fault of the media. It is his fault.

 

I think this is also a strategy, and has been one for some time: targeting the media and presenting them as targets for attack because they have pointed to his abuse of power, which also led to the massive demonstrations.

 

Regarding Informer, this outlet has been one of the worst propaganda outlets. I would not even call it a media outlet. I would call it an anti-media outlet. It looks like a media organization: it broadcasts, operates an online website and publishes news and commentary. But in fact, it does not respect journalistic ethics, the principles of pluralism or basic journalistic honesty. The use of basic journalistic methods is very strange to Informer. This is how we have regarded Informer, not as a media outlet.

 

On the other hand, nothing justifies violence or physical attacks. No opinion justifies physical attacks. I am very glad that the Student List called on people not to physically attack Informer’s staff.

 

N1 – We have also seen some changes in reporting. The public broadcaster in Vojvodina apologized to viewers for its reporting in recent years. Is an apology enough?

 

Szalai – The Student List’s victory clearly ushers in a new era for press freedom. It is a historic opportunity for progress in Serbia, which has ranked last in our World Press Freedom Index in the EU-Balkan region and reached its lowest-ever position in our index, at 104th out of 180 countries.

 

One of the reasons for this is political control of the public media. The apology broadcast by RTV Vojvodina is not enough. It is a first step, and it is positive. Mistakes have to be acknowledged, and those who allowed and managed this propaganda machine have to be held responsible.

 

But what we and the citizens of Serbia need, and what the country’s public media need, is a reset. It is not even a reform. It really is a reset. We have to acknowledge that the system needs to be rebuilt from scratch.

 

Things are moving much faster than in Hungary. There, it took weeks for the public broadcaster to apologize for spreading propaganda. Here, we saw it happen the day after the election. But it is essential to insist on systemic change, going beyond apologies and reshuffles in newsrooms or at management and CEO level.

 

N1 – Do you expect further attacks on independent media, or can we now breathe freely?

 

I also have to mention news we received 10 minutes ago, published by Nova S: the new management under Alpac Capital has said it will shut down the Nova newspaper on October 31. That is the latest news. How do you see this development?

 

Szalai – I think the purchase of Adria News Network, which includes Nova and N1, before the election, with non-transparent funding and accompanied by managerial decisions and interference in the newsroom, was not made for commercial reasons but for other reasons.

 

Developments before the election, including very drastic changes in the newsroom, suggest that the purchase was made for political reasons.

 

You mentioned the new decision, which is concerning, about the closure of the Nova S website. I would have to look into it and establish whether there is any justification. The problem with these steps so far has been the lack of justification, including the decision to stop broadcasting Nova and replace it with N1.

 

I think we also need independent regulatory authorities to regulate the media and media market in Serbia, so that pluralism in the market and within the media is preserved. We need a functioning REM, an authority that works independently and applies the law. Under President Vucic, this was not the case.

 

I know this is also a priority for the Student List, and I commend it. If N1 and Nova S cease to be independent, it will essentially mean the end of pluralism in Serbia and the completion of media capture. This is paradoxical now, of course, because Vucic lost the election.

 

Other scenarios are possible, naturally. Opportunism does not die; it flourishes under every regime. But we will be watching the situation very closely. I hope that Nova, N1 and their staff will retain their independence.

 

N1 – Yes, that is the question I wanted to ask you. What would be the reason for putting pressure on independent media now?

 

Szalai – I do not know. I cannot see into these people’s heads. I just know that no amount of money can buy trust.

 

However much money you pour into the media, whoever you appoint to management positions, however well-paid those people are, and whatever political connections you have, you cannot buy public trust.

 

Before these changes were made, trust among Serbians and viewers of Nova and N1 was strong. This is also why these changes do not make much sense from a business point of view. I do not see a clear business plan.

 

Let us hope these people can think rationally and that the political change will also influence how they deal with the media.

 

But the media are not just another product or another business where you can do whatever you want. They also serve the public interest and are regulated by law and journalistic ethics. This needs to be taken into account and applied in Serbia in this case as well.

 

Source: N1

Tags

highlighted news

Related posts